Bonhoeffer's Understanding of Grace in Life Together
The understanding of grace which Bonhoeffer provides in his book Life Together is primarily an understanding which reflects itself in concrete terms. For Bonhoeffer, much like Luther, grace is not a metaphorical concept, but rather the manifestation of God and his people in real ways that directly impact the world and people around them, or as Doberstein writes in the introduction to his translation of Life Together, “Christianity could never be merely intellectual theory, doctrine divorced from life, or mystical emotion, but always I must be responsible, obedient action, the discipleship of Christ in every situation of concrete everyday life, personal and public.” And, as this quote reveals, Christians themselves are agents of grace, not simply recipients.
Bonhoeffer's idea of grace as concrete reality begins with his understanding of God's grace towards man. He states, “It is by the grace of God that a congregation is permitted to gather visibly in this world to share God's Word and Sacrament.” Bonhoeffer believes that God's grace is exemplified in the plain fact that first, Christians have existence, and further in that in that existence there is a place for Christians to gather together in a way that we can worship God through His sacraments. Bonhoeffer also rightly notes in this that not all people have this privilege of public meeting, but even in that, there is some grace in the solitude of faith.
This grace however does not simply stop at the semi-abstract idea of mere existence. Grace, to Bonhoeffer, exists in our relationship with other people. Our opportunities daily to relate and love others is an extension of God's grace This is a primary foundation for much of what Bonhoeffer understood as grace in our daily experience – our God-enabled relationship with others.
This God enabled relationship in a God-enabled existence is not the end of God's grace in our life experience, however. As Bonhoeffer wrote - ”it is grace, nothing but grace, that we are allowed to live in community with Christian brethren” To Dietrich Bonhoeffer, the idea of Christians relating to other Christians itself was a prime example of God's grace, made possible by the teachings and Spirit of Christ. Without Jesus Christ to mediate between Christians there is no familial fellowship between brother and sister, brother and brother, or sister and sister.
Familial bonds in Christ are a way for Christians to both grow, and to experience God's grace. By relating God's grace to one another, Christians become agents of grace towards other Christians. This grace manifests itself in the common and worship lives of Christians.
“the community of Christians springs solely from the Biblical and Reformation message of the justification of man through grace alone,” declares Bonhoeffer as he explains the foundation of the relationship of Christians towards each other. Because they are all saved by grace, they have an intimate familiarity of common experience and self-understanding that allows Christians to relate to one another in a special and gracious way. Bonhoeffer builds on this thought as he continues on in his theology, explaining his understanding of grace. As Graessle notes, Bonhoeffer moves “from the concept of the church as communion of saints (Communio sanctorum is the title of his doctoral thesis), as "Christ existing as a community,”” until he reaches, “a church which has to re-construct itself.”
Because grace in community cannot simply stop at the communion of saints, and must affect the totality of the structure of the Church, and also the way in which Christians live their daily lives, Bonehoeffer outlines what the life of how Christians should act as a family unit, and also as individuals. It is, Bonhoffer believed, necessary for us to be thankful for us to have an increasing amount of grace in our lives - “we prevent God from giving us the great spiritual gifts he has in store for us, because we do not give thanks for daily gifts.” This attitude of thankfulness towards God for the grace we have been given is an attitude that will reflect itself in the way we treat others. And, our overcoming an attitude of thanklessness is made possible by God's grace, which itself was exemplified ”when God's son took on flesh, he truly and bodily took on, out of pure grace, our being, our nature, ourselves.”
Our ability to relate to each other in community and grow in grace, which was taught to us and made possible for us by God is the foundation of our grace as Christians towards other Christians. “Christian community is like the Christian's sanctification. It is a gift of God which we cannot claim. Only God knows the real state of our fellowship, of our sanctification. What may appear weak and trifling to us may be great and glorious to God,” is the idea that should underly Christian community relationship of grace towards one another, Bonhoeffer writes. And, as we exist together, and are agents of grace to one another, God's grace is even more a part of a Christian's daily life. We grow closer to God and Godliness as we grow closer to Christ together.
Beyond our relationship with each other in community, Bonhoeffer also emphasizes the idea of the Scriptures as a means of grace. “[God's Word] strives to stir us, to work and operate in us, so that we shall not get away from it the whole day long. Then it will do its work in us, often without our being conscious of it.” Our time spent in prayer, reading, and meditation on the scripture provides a means for us to grow more like Christ when otherwise such growth would be beyond our ability.
And, it is the truths contained in the Scriptures that are what hold Christians together in fellowship with one another - ”it is the grace of the Gospel, which is so hard for the pious to understand, that it confronts us with the truth and says: You are a sinner, a great, desperate sinner; now come, as the sinner that you are, to God who loves you.” This compels us to face up to the truth that Kaessman writes, “God seeks to overcome the suffering in this world with the power of love alone--not with war, empires or violence. Whoever uses the name of God should remember that,”
This life, this fellowship, and this understanding of grace as outlined by the teachings of scripture points Bonhoeffer to the understanding of the Eucharist as the highest form of Christian fellowship – whereby one group of people might come together in the presence of God to both celebrate his grace, remembering that “the fellowship bears the sin of the brother,” and emphasizing the need for repentance and confession before entering into the practice of Holy Communion And, by celebrating communion in fellowship with other believers with whom they are in right, Christ-centered relationship, the Believers experience Christ's grace and forgiveness as taken through the physical elements.
As has been shown, all of Bonhoeffer's understandings of what constitutes grace is always expressed in concrete, real, terms. God's grace is expressed in the Creation where man exists, the modes by which He has man approach him, such as confession, prayer, communion, and the Scriptures. These ways for man to approach God are then opportunities for people to become more like Christ, without any particular action of the man himself, but rather the further manifestation of God's grace made real in the way that God changes the person. This Christ-likeness resulting from God's grace enables a person to offer other people grace in their own personal lives, either by offering community or encouragement, or even by taking (or giving) their own confession – all are God's grace for man to experience. This understanding in mind, Bonhoeffer's understanding of grace could be said to be this - “grace is the physical and real manifestation of God's love for humankind which people then experience directly in their own lives or in the lives of the Church as a body.”
Bibliography.
Bonhoeffer, Dietrich. Life Together. Trans. By John Doberstein. San Francisco, Harper and Row, 1954.
Graessle, Isabelle. “From Impasse to Passage” The Ecumenical Review, Vol. 53, 2001, pg 25. Available online from http://www.questia.com/read/5000956508?title=From%20Impasse%20to%20Passage last accessed 22 April 2009
Kaessma, Margot. “For the Healing of the World” The Ecumenical Review, Vol. 56, 2004, pg 20. Available online from http://www.questia.com/read/5006441582?title=For%20the%20Healing%20of%20the%20World last accessed 22 April 2009
Chatboard (0)